News 
 Lifestyle 
 Entertainment 
 TV 
 Now it's Australia's Got Plagiarism? 

Now it's Australia's Got Plagiarism?

26 May, 2011 11:06 AM
A Gold Coast stand-up who's made it through to the semi-finals of Australia's Got Talent did so by lifting jokes from other comedians' routines.

Jordan Paris, 22, appeared on the Channel Seven program on Tuesday night to laughter from judges Dannii Minogue, Brian McFadden and Kyle Sandilands, who unanimously voted him through to the next round.

Sandilands described his jokes as ''legitimately funny'' while Minogue said he did the Gold Coast ''proud''.

But today it emerged both jokes Paris told in the routine were ripped off from other sources.

The Gold Coast Bulletin this morning reported how one joke - about singer Robbie Williams - was taken almost word-for-word from a set performed by British comedian Lee Mack in 2007.

And a quick search by brisbanetimes.com.au this morning revealed the origins of the other half of Mr Paris' routine - about his three requirements for dating a woman - had been directly lifted from a routine by US comedian Geoff Keith.

The joke is repeated almost word-for-word.

Mr Paris told the Bulletin he knew of Lee Mack but hadn't ripped off his routine.

''Comedy's a funny thing," he told the newspaper. ''Obviously there are a lot of people doing a lot of things, but a joke's a joke. If it's making people laugh then I'm happy."

Channel Seven this morning would not comment on whether Mr Paris would now be disqualified from the show.

Contestants on Australia's Got Talent, which is now in its fourth year, compete for a prize of $250,000.

It's one of Australia's top-rating television programs, drawing more than 1.8 million viewers on Tuesday night, 500,000 more than the second most-watched show, MasterChef.

While cover versions of songs frequently appear, Fedele Crisci, of Brisbane's Sit Down Comedy Club, said repeating another comedian's routine was nothing like a singer singing someone else's song.

''Stand-up is a very different kettle of fish,'' he said. ''[Copying jokes] is very much frowned upon. People have their routines and people in the industry know whose routines are whose.

''It's not the done thing.''

Mr Crisci said comedians sometimes would take use a ''stock-standard old joke'' but they'd put their own spin on it and incorporate it into part of a bigger routine.

''The bottom line is we encourage people to be original,'' he said. ''That’s what it’s about. Anyone can go to America and watch a comic and come back and do [that comic's] act.

''You need to write your own material.''

Mr Paris' manager has been approached for comment. On his website, Mr Paris describes himself as a singer, actor and comedian who had previously appeared on television when he auditioned for Australian Idol.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Isn't the whole show plagiarised from the US version?
Posted by watermellon, 26/05/2011 11:40:01 AM
What's the big deal? 99.9% of the bands/singers on there sang someone elses song, Newcastle's Viagro were one of only a couple of bands that played originals and got throw. The old cow cocky comedian used jokes straight out of the picture magazine.

And Watermellon it isn't plagiarised at all it is licensed to Simon Cowell who produces both Britian's and America's got talent.

Posted by Steve, 26/05/2011 12:03:26 PM
coz so many of the singers do original material not.
Posted by old fart, 26/05/2011 12:07:03 PM
The show is called Australia's Got Talent. It takes practice, patience and the ability to sing someone elses song to pull it off.

I could go watch Robin Williams, copy his jokes and repeat it to my work collegues and gain a laugh. Tell me how that is "talented"?

Posted by Morgan, 26/05/2011 2:27:53 PM
My my, aren't we becoming a bit rediculous about this. He delivered it brilliantly, so what's the big deal.

I see nobody claimed his Luna Park face, did they? Good onya man. Keep it up, that smile is worth a mint. However, I do hope you have enough there to keep us laughing.. & Please, don't get smutty, Crude or rude with it, or you'll lose me. Anyone who needs smutt to get a laugh, ain't funny. Go Jordan!!

Posted by HollyMolly, 26/05/2011 9:09:47 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Entertainer Jordan Paris says comedy's a funny thing. Pic: jordanparis.com
Entertainer Jordan Paris says "comedy's a funny thing". Pic: jordanparis.com

Most popular articles


click here
 
Sydney Writers Festival


Rouse Hill Stanhope Garden News







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...